We Asked Benjamin Moser to Name One Artwork He Considers a “Revelation”

0

Glowing harmlessly on the walls of the Century Association on Manhattan’s West 43rd Street is a work by John Frederick Kensett. It shows Mount Chocorua, in the White Mountains of New Hampshire. Today, in an age of easy travel to more exotic climes, this peak looms a bit less spectacularly than it did in the 19th century, when it was a kind of American Matterhorn: sung by our poets; painted by our artists; haunted, thrillingly, by a spooky legend—of an Indian chief named Chocorua who, after cursing the whites, threw himself off its summit.

Kensett, the son of a British engraver who emigrated to New Haven, Connecticut, gazes out with rheumy eyes from the pictures I have found of him. His paintings have the Hudson River School’s luminosity, that sense of dawn or sunset—of warm autumn, not blazing summer or bleak winter. They show an undisturbed arcadia inhabited by men who sleep restfully and arise to purposeful labor, a view that, seen from honking Manhattan, beckons with the promise of picnics and porches and swims in the lake, an image of a better—purer—happier age.

But if you take the tiniest step out of this scene—away from its gentle mountains, its neat wooden farmhouse, its grazing flocks—you might be arrested by the date on the frame: 1864. This picture was painted one year after Gettysburg and the Emancipation Proclamation, one year before Appomattox and the assassination of Lincoln, in the year of the slaughter of tens of thousands during the Wilderness Campaign, in the year of the burning of Atlanta. Perhaps never in our history had the country’s reality been so distant from this gently golden image.

Looking at it in our own dreadful times, I see a man summoning the courage to step away from the news and create an image—not of the country tearing itself apart in a horrifying war, but of a country that might yet emerge from that war: not the nation as it was, but the nation that might yet be. So while I see everything missing from this picture—slavery, genocide, war—I see, rather than a flight from the reality of our history, a summons to overcome that history: to look, even through bloodshot eyes, and dare to envision a better world.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here